15/01/2006

 

Lessons in ‘usual truth’, Sangh style

Memories of my visit to a RSS-run school in north Bihar’s Darbhanga, four years ago, were refreshed recently with the news that the Sangh has decided to open schools and hospitals in all blocks of Khunti. Then the “pradhanadhyapak”, as the headmaster in the RSS schools is referred to, in that desolate Darbhanga village school was engrossed in teaching his pupils that: “President A.P.J Abdul Kalam was a Hindu”. Intrigued, I had asked how would such a false description help the students. The pradhanadhyapak had promptly replied: “Kalam reads the Geeta, Ramayana and other Hindu scriptures, besides the Quran Sharief. Moreover, he is the President of Hindustan; that’s why he is a Hindu. I am teaching the usual truth”. What the teacher preached as an “usual truth” was quite unusual to me prompting me to write a story, which the national daily I had been associated with then, published on its front page.

I wondered if the schools, that were to be opened in Khunti, a place dotted with a wide network of Christian missionary schools, would teach the “usual truth” as well.

While pondering over the RSS decision, I informed our editor of the rightwing Hindu oufit’s decision to open schools in Khuti, suggesting that the news be published prominently. But the editor shot back: “What is so special about the RSS opening schools in Khunti? Try and investigate what they have contributed to the field of education so far. Nanaji Deshmukh adopted Singhbhum in the early 1970s. Did it make any difference to the region?”

The editor had questioned the very purpose of the institutions. After a little bit of investigation, I too, have no reason to disagree with the editor on the issue. The RSS has been running schools known as Saraswati Vidya Mandir in the city’s Dhurva locality since 1971, which claims to have 2,600 students as of now. Its Chutia-based Saraswati Vidya Mandir, too, is about 15 years-old. Similarly, the RSS runs a wide network of such schools in remote areas of Santhal Pargana and Chhotanagpur for over three or four decades.

But the state hardly knows any product of Saraswati Vidya Mandir earning a name in the field of science, literature, economics, journalism and bureaucracy. Are there litterateurs like Amitav Ghosh and Vikram Seth, or scientists like A.P.J. Abdul Kalam, or economists like Amartya Sen, who had their primary education in RSS-run schools? No. Jharkhad has its share of excellent academics. For instance the historian K. K. Dutta whose birth centenary is being celebrated and anthropologist L. P. Vidyarthi. Did the likes of Vidyathis and Duttas ever study in RSS institutions? No.

The problem is that the RSS has been so busy trying to counter the “evil” impact of Christian missionaries since Golvalkar’s days that they have simply failed to match the standard of the missionary schools. Interestingly, the leaders of the BJP and RSS’s political wing don’t send their children to RSS schools. For instance, chief minister Arjun Munda opted for a Banglore-based Christian missionary school to admit his son rather than the Saraswati Vidya Mandir. None of the top Sangh Parivar’s leaders like Arun Shourie, Arun Jaitley, Yashwant Singh and Pramod Mahajan have ever studied in the schools, which emphasizes on “Bhartiyata” and despises “western” influence. Many top “parivar” leaders have opted for Christian missionary schools as well. Let me clarify that I have nothing against RSS-run schools. But they will have to impart quality education in the field of science, arts and literature if they are genuinely striving to compete with other schools. The RSS should take notice of the fact that Nagpur, where it is headquartered, attracts students for offering quality education in science, computer and management. Few visit Nagpur to learn lessons in Hindutva, fanaticism and falsehood.

(Courtesy The Telegraph)

 

Nalin Verma

The Author is the Ranchi based special correspondent of the Telegraph

Comment..

 

Comments...